The following is a guest post written by David B. Lever.
David B. Lever founded the law firm, David B. Lever & Associates, PLLC in 2014 and is the firm’s top legal strategist. He has fought for the rights of accident victims and consumers for over 24 years. His area of practice is Personal Injury-Plaintiff, which includes construction accidents.
In March 2013, Flintlock Construction was building a hotel at a Manhattan construction site known as the 325 Project. OSHA inspectors visited the site and delivered three separate scaffolding violations that added up to a total of $249,920 in OSHA fines. Flintlock Construction immediately filed an appeal and that appeal was heard in July 2015.
The result of the appeal was that the fines were upheld. It was determined that Flintlock did put its employees in a dangerous situation with their lack of attention to scaffolding laws. OSHA was created to look out for worker safety, and OSHA did submit a response to the appeal that was filled with nearly 40 pages of explanations for each violation. Flintlock is appealing again, but the evidence suggests that the final appeal will meet with the same fate as this most recent one.
The Details Of The Case
During a safety inspection, OSHA noted three separate major scaffolding violations at the 325 Project job site. These violations included scaffolding located near the:
- Southeast corner of the building
- North side of the building
- Building entrance where a plank walkway was considered unsafe
OSHA takes scaffolding violations very seriously and has laid out the rules for proper scaffolding in forms that are available to all contractors. The key component to all of these scaffolding laws is the overriding theme of worker safety. Scaffolding must be properly constructed, maintained, and secured before it can be used by employees. It is the initial complaint and subsequent appeal, where OSHA noted that the scaffolding in these three areas did not meet legal specifications.
The Depth Of The Problem
OSHA noted that these were "willful and serious violations" committed by Flintlock Construction. As we examine the fines given by OSHA, it is important to look at the wording OSHA uses when referring to these fines. The word "willful" stands out because it indicates how severe OSHA considers Flintlock's violations to be, and that explains the excessive amount of the fines that were levied.
In its appeal, Flintlock maintained that the discretions were not willful because the main principals of the company did not know that the violations were taking place. But the response given by OSHA to the appeal shows that there was communication between the field and Flintlock's corporate office and that communication did, on several occasions, try to warn the office of pending issues.
Analyzing The Appeal Decision
The written decision by OSHA regarding the appeal goes into explicit detail regarding the conditions leading up to the inspection, the communications between the field and corporate office, and the communications within the office itself. The most damaging evidence to Flintlock Construction is the field log of George DeCristoforo, who was the field supervisor for a subcontractor called Site Safety. Mr. DeCristoforo's logs explain the issues with the site scaffolding in great detail. The logs then go into comprehensive detail about the responses he got from Flintlock Construction management when he would voice his concerns.
The record shows that the project managers at every level in Flintlock Construction were made aware of the potential scaffolding issues, but they all chose to ignore the problems. One Flintlock supervisor went so far as to tell Mr. DeCristoforo that the supervisor was in "no mood to listen to concerns" about worker safety and potential scaffolding violations.
The Final Appeal Could Be Pointless
The worksite logs from the 325 Project and the interviews conducted with various members of the construction team that are all documented in the OSHA response to the appeal are difficult to ignore. The evidence shows that each level of Flintlock management was made aware of the issues, but yet no corrective action was taken.
In analyzing a situation like this, it is important to look at both sides of the equation. Flintlock supervisors are quoted in the OSHA decision as knowing that the scaffolding was unsafe, but they were attempting to reach a deadline set by the project owner. None of the Flintlock personnel that was interviewed denied cutting corners on worker safety to meet this deadline, and that is not going to help Flintlock in its final attempt at an appeal.
In February, the House of Representatives voted 236-187 on a resolution to block the ‘blacklisting' rule, sending it to the Senate for a second vote. The act would have given the federal government the ability to disqualify contractors if they violated any of the 14 labor laws, which can be found here, over the past 3 years on any project totaling $500,000 or more
As of the first quarter of 2016, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reports that there are over 768,000 construction companies currently operating in the private industry in America. There are also countless more that have come and gone. According to Statistic Brain, only 47% of construction startup businesses are still operating after year 4. Personally, I've seen many people break off from a construction company and create their own business; some are still in operation, others have failed.
OSHA inspectors and city building officials are usually the people that can make life pretty uncomfortable for construction companies, but it’s a whole different story when the FBI comes calling. A new stadium for the Double-A minor league baseball team, the Hartford Yard Goats, was supposed to open before the 2016 season, but delays and cost overruns have pushed that opening well into 2017. Now, the FBI is investigating, according to the Hartford Courant.
In an announcement made in mid-January, the US EPA has officially released the updated 2017 Construction General Permit (CGP) for Stormwater Discharges from Construction Activities. The draft of the new permit was released last year and the 45 day public comment period ended on May 26, 2016. The 2017 CGP will go into effect starting February 16, 2016.
In July of 2016, the Fair Pay and Safe Workplaces Executive Order was signed into effect and has been a hotbed of controversy, especially within the construction industry, ever since. The act would have given the federal government the ability to disqualify contractors if they violated any of the 14 labor laws, which can be found here, over the past 3 years on any project totaling $500,000 or more.
Trenches are a construction jobsite hazard that happen on nearly every construction site involving dirt work, but, all too often their dangers are underestimated. In fact, trench related deaths in 2016 have more than doubled as compared to 2015. There’s no excuse for allowing a trench related death to happen, but it’s rare that job site supervision suffers criminal charges after one occurs. After the death of a 22 year old New York construction worker, the Manhattan District Attorney’s office took a hard stance against those responsible and announced formally sentenced the on-site foreman last week.
2016 has been a tough year for people that live in ocean-near luxury high rise condos. The Millennium Tower in San Francisco, California, which is home to many of the city’s rich and famous residents, has found itself in the middle of several lawsuits after it was determined to have sunk around 16 inches since its opening in 2008. Now, it appears that it’s not the only luxury tower in America with foundation issues.
It’s been a tumultuous year between several governmental agencies and businesses alike and, because of that, both sides have been repeatedly put into a state of limbo. Three new major rule changes have made headlines, especially in the construction industry, this year, including an injury and illness record keeping and reporting rule, a “blacklisting” rule, and an overtime pay rule.
Modular construction has been heralded by many as the next big thing in building structures quickly and cost effectively. By being able to construct parts of the building in a controlled environment, like a factory, workers can perform more efficiently, comfortably, and safely, ideally translating into shorter schedules and smaller costs. That theory got one of its biggest tests on a new 32-story residential building that recently opened in Brooklyn, NY.
It’s been a strenuous year for leading construction industry groups and American government agencies. Three controversial new rules, that were supposed to have been in effect at this point, have ignited a heated battle, including some lawsuits. New overtime pay rules, a ‘blacklisting’ rule, and an injury illness record keeping and reporting rule have been successfully delayed by leading construction industry groups. Below is a summary of the recent developments: